The Bozeman Brief
City Commission

Commission raises water fee for first time since 2008 and approves Fowler housing annexation with RB zoning after consensus process

City Commission — November 10, 2026

The Bozeman City Commission unanimously approved a new cash-in-lieu of water rights fee of $13,050 per acre-foot, effective March 1, 2027, and directed staff to annex and zone the Fowler housing site as RB with conditions including a two-story height limit next to Harvest Creek. Both actions followed extensive public engagement.

| Published November 11, 2026

The Bozeman City Commission approved two major initiatives at its November 10th meeting: a water rights fee increase and an annexation and zoning designation for the Fowler housing project, both actions passing unanimously after substantial public engagement.

Water Rights Fee Increase

The commission approved 5-0 a resolution establishing the cash-in-lieu of water rights fee at $13,050 per acre-foot, with an effective date of March 1, 2027. The fee, which had not been updated since 2008, will increase from $6,000 per acre-foot to $13,050 — roughly doubling the cost per single-family home from $1,400 to $3,000, and raising the cost per apartment unit to about $1,500.

Adam Jokurst of Westwater Research presented three independent valuation methods — full cost recovery, fair market value, and cost of new water supply development — which produced ranges from $4,900 to $15,000 per acre-foot. The recommended midpoint of $13,050 falls within the suggested range of $11,600 to $14,500. Jokurst noted that despite the increase, Bozeman's fee remains competitive with peer communities in the West when measured against median new home prices.

Utilities Director Sean Coates confirmed the city has been undercharging for water. The last Highline Reservoir share purchase by the city occurred more than six years ago at the $6,000 level. Coates identified a state-level bottleneck: the Department of Natural Resources and Conservation stepped into the share transfer process about five years ago, preventing the city from purchasing additional shares despite increased post-pandemic demand.

The Community Development Board had recommended phasing the increase over time, and several written public comments made the same request. Commissioner Sweeney moved for approval at the full amount, arguing against phasing and comparing the per-home cost to standard construction hardware. She also raised concern that if the cash-in-lieu fund runs short, the gap would fall on the water enterprise fund and therefore on ratepayers.

The primary disagreement was over implementation timing. The original resolution proposed November 23rd. Commissioners Bode and Fischer both argued the date did not allow adequate time, noting the upcoming holidays and that staff estimated three months for developers to file a subdivision modification to pay at the current rate. Mayor Morrison alone advocated for the original date, citing the city's code provision that the fee owed is the fee in effect when paid. Commissioner Bode moved to amend the effective date to March 1, 2027. That amendment passed 5-0, and the main motion passed 5-0.

Fowler Housing Annexation and Zoning

The commission voted 5-0 to direct the city manager to submit an annexation and zoning application for the roughly 10-acre Fowler property with an RB zoning designation, along with a subdivision exemption separating the road lot from the residential lot. The decision culminated an 11-month consensus-building process involving 49 individual interviews, three structured listening circles, and two community design charrettes.

Communications and Engagement Director Takami Clark outlined the process timeline, which began in June 2025 with public open houses and accelerated after an August 2025 commission meeting revealed substantial neighborhood opposition. Diane Groves of Whole System Performance designed and facilitated the first two phases, establishing that the consensus process was not a vote but rather a tool for community learning and building a shared information base. Groves noted the commission had set boundaries going into phase two: below-market homeownership for households earning approximately 110 to 150 percent of area median income, and no four- or five-story development.

Jimmy Tallarico of Cushing Terrell presented phase three outcomes. Community feedback indicated "clear opposition" to RC zoning. Between RA and RB, Tallarico said both could theoretically align with the community's ten guiding principles, but RA zoning creates challenges for ensuring financial and operational sustainability. Economic Development Manager David Fine explained that infrastructure costs — water, sewer, alleys, and sidewalks — must run the full length of the site regardless of unit count, making fewer units economically infeasible without substantially higher subsidies.

The consensus recommendation was RB zoning with specific conditions: buildings adjacent to existing Harvest Creek homes limited to a maximum of two stories; buildings along Fowler may reach a maximum of three stories; and no building may contain more than four homes. Tallarico said these conditions emerged from community discussions about mass, scale, and the feel of buildings relative to neighborhood character.

Staff presented a resolution rather than a simple verbal direction to memorialize the commission's intent. City Attorney Greg Sullivan explained that under Montana law, the city cannot place a deed restriction on property it owns without transferring ownership. The resolution was intended to record the commission's direction for the future site planning process and to restore public confidence after previous concerns about commitments made on the same parcel in 2017.

Public comment revealed both strong support and requests for stronger protections. Nathan Stein of Headwaters Community Housing Trust, a nonprofit formed to address affordability, noted that the October 2026 median home sale price in Bozeman was $825,000 — "more than double what the median household in this community can afford." He urged the commission to move forward with RB zoning and the staff-recommended resolution language.

Several Harvest Creek residents and neighbors asked for additional commitments. Heather Higs, representing the Harvest Creek Owners Association, pointed to a 2017 commission resolution on the same parcel whose six conditions were never recorded in the warranty deed. "The residents of Harvest Creek are here tonight so that history is not repeated," she said. Noah Lopez, a New Holland Drive homeowner, and Mary Frances McHugh both recommended that the resolution commit the city to recording deed restrictions if the property is ever transferred. Tom Gay suggested making the consensus conditions binding on the annexation itself, enforceable if not met.

One participant in phase three, Natsuki Nakamura, questioned whether trade-offs were fully explored, saying discussion prompts assumed density guaranteed affordability without examining what RA zoning could produce. She noted that Cushing Terrell's consultant had acknowledged affordability was possible in RA but would require different trade-offs.

In commission discussion, Commissioner Bode said she had explored allowing six-unit buildings using a central stairwell design to fit more affordably on the narrow site, but staff cautioned that the site's shape made such a configuration less suitable. She noted the process had generated clear consensus on mass and scale, and she chose to honor that. Bode said public comment that evening — which showed substantial support for the process and recommendations — influenced her final position: "It's because you all in this room honored and agreed with the consensus process, that I tonight am also honoring and agreeing with the consensus process."

Fine described the core tension: "The consensus process produced agreement on project elements, but that agreement may be the proverbial square peg and the zoning designations are the round hole." He said the four-unit recommendation came directly from what the community process produced, even though designers could theoretically work with more units.

Deputy Mayor Fischer then proposed adding a subsection to the resolution committing the city, should it ever sell or transfer the land, to encumber the property with the site design elements in the resolution. Commissioner Bode moved that amendment. It passed 5-0. The main motion directing annexation and zoning with RB designation passed 5-0.

Mayor Morrison expressed one reservation about the process itself: that it placed staff in a position of defending the integrity of the consensus outcome, rather than presenting neutral criteria for the commission to decide. He noted the experiment had taken considerable time and cost, and he questioned whether staff should bear that burden in future processes.

Other commission reflections: Commissioner Sweeney said she still believed the site could have supported neighborhood-scale commercial — a coffee shop or bakery that could unite the neighborhoods — but supported the consensus outcome. She called out the need for clarity on how missing middle housing typologies fit into broader zoning code. City Manager Chuck Winn emphasized that the project remains feasible under these constraints and can deliver "a cool, innovative, flagship, affordable project."

Staff was directed to notify developers who deferred cash-in-lieu payment at the time they filed applications, giving them an opportunity to pay at the current rate before March 1st. The Fowler annexation and zoning application will move through the standard planning department process over approximately six months, with a community check-in expected after that.

The meeting also included a presentation by the Veterans Alliance of Southwest Montana, which donated funds to the city for the Southwest Montana Veterans Cemetery, which opened on Veterans Day 2024. The alliance reported contributing more than $200,000 to date. The consent agenda of 17 items passed 5-0, including a grant agreement covering impact fees for the Bozeman Montessori annexation and approval to apply for a grant studying resilience systems at the Public Safety Center.

water rightshousingFowlerzoningaffordabilitydevelopment
Free to republish. This article and its audio may be reprinted or republished for free, in whole or in part, with credit to CivicCast (The Bozeman Brief) and a link back to this page. Please don't edit the piece to imply we endorse your organization, and verify details against the official meeting recording before relying on them.