The Bozeman Historic Preservation Advisory Board held an extended work session November 18 to review proposed revisions to city code related to historic preservation, wrestling with questions about the board's advisory role under state law while offering detailed feedback on dozens of code sections.
The meeting, delayed by technical difficulties, centered on a package of amendments that reorganizes existing historic preservation regulations to align with Bozeman's new Unified Development Code. Most of the proposed changes move existing rules from the Neighborhood Conservation Overlay District section into separate code chapters covering submittal requirements, design standards, and other procedural matters. Staff emphasized that these are working drafts open to revision.
Board Role and State Law Constraints
The most contentious issue involved proposed language limiting the board's formal review role. The draft removes language allowing the board to "review and comment" on planning and zoning programs, replacing it with authority to advise "when requested" by staff or the City Commission. City Attorney Greg Sullivan explained that the Montana Local Government Policy Act (MLUPA) assigns land use regulatory authority exclusively to planning commissions—implemented locally by the Community Development Board—and that assigning overlapping formal roles to other boards could conflict with state law. The board cannot, he stated, formally review zone map amendments or annexations.
Board members, particularly Allyson Brekke and Chelsea Holling, challenged this formulation, arguing it could leave the board unused if staff or commissioners never request input. Holling suggested language allowing the board to "may advise, on its own initiative or upon request," on matters affecting historic resources. "I do not trust the City Commission asking us," she said. "I think there's a way for us to just be part of those discussions." Mitchell Korus proposed using "may" instead of "when requested," viewing it as more permissive. Staff said they would explore alternative wording with legal counsel.
Board members also pointed out that the board's purpose statement—revised to reflect supporting a local historic preservation program and integrating preservation into local, state, and federal planning and decision-making—seemed to conflict with the restricted advisory role being proposed. Erin George, Community Development Director, countered that the board has been extensively involved in code revisions for three years, noting that this ongoing policy work is distinct from development applications.
Code Reorganization Details
Staff presented a systematic review of proposed changes section by section. Key modifications include:
Purpose and Intent: Proposed deletions remove language specific to the original 1984 survey boundaries defining the NCOD as a historic district, allowing the overlay concept to potentially apply more broadly across the city. The board agreed to removing language about enhancing property values, though members suggested retaining language about economic stabilization or neighborhood stabilization benefits.
Staff Positions: The draft removes references to hiring, qualifications, and duties of a historic preservation officer, moving such details to city Human Resources and job descriptions. Staff confirmed this is consistent with the city charter, which assigns hiring authority to the city manager. SHPO consultation is planned to ensure certified local government status is preserved.
Certificate of Appropriateness Submittal Requirements: The board confirmed that exceptions to COA requirements—for fences, basement egress windows, accessory structures under 120 square feet, roof material alterations, and certain photovoltaic panels—will be maintained. Staff indicated discussion is ongoing about potentially adding window replacements to exemptions.
Administrative Deviations: The board discussed criteria for allowing deviations from zoning code for historic structures. Height deviations are proposed for removal. The revised criteria explicitly reference adaptive reuse, with one criterion stating a deviation is appropriate if "necessary to retain, repair, or adaptively reuse the historic resource." Board members noted this better articulates the original intent to incentivize preservation. Appeals of deviations would proceed first to the Community Development Board, then to the City Commission, under MLUPA procedures.
Board member James Webster raised a question about whether deviations had been tracked historically and whether the board should monitor future deviation requests in relation to code changes.
Contributing vs. Non-Contributing Status
Allyson Brekke raised a broader question about how staff determines when a structure loses its contributing status to a historic district due to alterations. She questioned whether a structure that has been altered should still be considered contributing, noting that alterations can theoretically be reversed and that a structure continues to contribute to district character even if modified. Director George explained that surveys evaluate both individual structure eligibility and relationship to districts, citing National Register criteria, and that staff consults with the city's historic preservation planner and SHPO when needed. Board members stressed the importance of maintaining updated surveys and GIS records to reflect these determinations.
Schedule and Next Steps
Staff outlined the timeline for remaining work. The board will review design guidelines and the new local landmark program in December. All sections will then be packaged into a single ordinance for legal review in December and January. Staff aims to present the full ordinance to HPAB in February for a public hearing and recommendation, followed by review by the Community Development Board and City Commission.
The board discussed attendance for the critical December 16 meeting, with several members noting they would be absent, raising questions about quorum. Director George said staff would follow up by email to confirm availability.
New Historic Preservation Planner
Staff introduced Chloe Bonson, the city's new Historic Preservation Planner, who began work several weeks ago. Bonson comes from Gallatin County, where she spent the previous year as an associate planner. She previously worked on historic preservation at Island County in Washington State, including work with the Ebey's Landing National Historic Reserve, and in Port Angeles on long-range planning and special projects. She holds a degree in urban planning and sustainable development with a minor in disaster risk reduction from Western Washington University. Bonson will work closely with the board as the design guidelines project advances, though Rebecca Harbage will continue as the board's formal staff liaison.
Board Priority Discussion
James Webster noted that the board had identified four priorities in January 2025: establishing a local historic preservation program, integrating historic preservation into planning processes, identifying and protecting historic resources, and public education. He suggested the board reassess its priorities given that four new members have joined since that assessment. Board members agreed this would be valuable, though staff noted that City Commission ultimately determines the board's official roles and responsibilities, potentially through resolution rather than code.
The meeting was extended to 9 p.m. to accommodate the full discussion. No public comment was received.